As a computer engineer major, I do not know much about the UH ICS program but here are some of my suggestions on how it could be improved:
1. There are lots of 400-level ICS courses listed in the UH Manoa catalog, but most seem to be offered once every couple of years. Having a survey or calendar of when certain courses may be offered, or emphasizing RadGrad, would be helpful in getting students into the classes that they want to take.
2. While I understand that the B minimum is there to ensure that students have a decent grasp of the material, it can turn the focus away from the learning and put it on the grade. It is also unfortunate that students may be set back a semester due to missing the B threshold by a very close margin in some instances.
3. Though the flipped classroom model provides students with flexibility, we can't get clarification right away when we do not understand.
What are three ways that the UH ICS program could improve?
1) Lack of socialization within the major. I find that oftentimes my only exposure to my peers is during occasional group projects. Other than this, I don't find that collaborating with others is something I do often because there are often guidelines for certain courses which make collaboration difficult (high suspicion of cheating).
2) Lack of continuity with Languages. I have learned a few different languages from different courses, but I easily forget what I learned a year or a few semesters ago because I learn a language once and then don't use it again.
3) Extreme competitiveness in regards to employment & internships. Perhaps the ICS program can reach out to more companies that would be interested in employing interns and graduates.
UH ICS Program is can improve by…
1: Providing tutoring for upper level classes: I think this is also a UH problem. Programs such as the Learning Emporium don’t provide tutoring beyond Freshman/Sophomore classes.
2: Making sure schedules don’t conflict: In my freshman year, courses were listed in such a way that there was only one combination of all the recommended classes that didn’t overlap. This led to the incoming freshman fighting to get this one schedule. I think the UH ICS Program should make sure that the timing of their recommended classes don’t conflict with each other.
3: Hosting a day to shadow a professional: I think it would be beneficial for students to be able to shadow a professional for a day. It would allow students to see what a day at a job they are interested in is like, as well as help them network with potential employers. It would also allow local companies to advertise their workplace, which might help stop the brain drain to the mainland.
What are three ways that the UH ICS program could improve?
1) Expand the ICS focus areas to include embeded development or operating systems (You don't have to have a EE or CE background to do this).
2) Have students make or participate in a vertically integrated project that is their focus from freshmen to senior year.
3) More courses should be available that are self-paced or online to go at the pace appropriate for the student.
One of the ways that the UH ICS program could improve is to advertise the various opportunities they have to the students more, and in a clear, concise manner. Many students discover the POST lab and study area through word of mouth from the older students. I, myself, heard about it, but never knew where it truly was before I happened to stumble upon them on my way to a professor's office. Another way the program could be improved is to have better communication with the Electrical Engineering department for Computer Engineers to allow a smooth transition for equivalent courses. Finally, it would be nice to have courses earlier on that go into certain topics within ICS so that students with interests in one field do not have to spend an exorbitant amount of time in a topic they are not interested in and will not be applying in their career choice.
I think the ICS Department could improve through:
1. More collaboration and structure between the ICS and Engineering departments, in terms of equivalent classes.
2. Implementation of undergraduate projects. This may help individuals to gain more experience while working on a team to solve problems. This could potentially help more students to get better jobs, as projects tend to be big discussion points in certain interviews. There are a lot of ICS111 and ICS314 projects being showcased, but work in each student's respective field of interest would be beneficial. These projects may also serve to build stronger relations between faculty and students. Open Power Quality seems like a great project, and more opportunities would definitely help.
3. Availability of a clear document that states the expected offering of ICS classes for future semesters and years.
1. Needing the necessary equipment. Though most students, if not all, have their own laptops, ICS requires a more optimal laptop resulting in a decent amount of money to spend. Though the trade off is not as many, if not none at all, textbook fees and while textbooks last a semester or two, the laptop is a worth while investment.
2. The competitive nature. ICS 111 had 300+ students in an auditorium which was culled down to about 60 students for 211 the following semester. With not enough professors or courses to take, it's competitive trying to get into classes you need while staying on track for graduation.
3. The amount of time and effort it takes. Though this could be said about many majors, from my personal experience, ICS has had me invest most of my time into it. Sometimes you have a bug and it takes you forever to find the error, other times you don't know how you want to solve the problem as there are many solutions and ways you can approach a situation, and sometimes you may just upright not know where to even begin. ICS teaches you a different set of problem solving skills you more than likely haven't seen anywhere else making it difficult in certain aspects.
Through the perspective of a computer engineering student, I think the information and computer sciences (ICS) program can improve the inclusion of engineering students into the program, the incorporation of more ICS related courses in the major and the provision of resources to its students.
First and foremost, I think the ICS program should put forth an effort to include engineers into the ICS program in a welcoming manner. At the moment, computer engineering students are required to email the computer science department to request for an override in order to register for classes that we need to take since computer engineering classes are not listed as a prerequisite. Even worse, some people are not aware of this, and therefore are surprised by this fact. This can result in late registration and even losing the ability to take the class due to limited seating. Having to endure this burden should not exist. A simple solution, if possible, is to add the required engineering classes to that prerequisite list so we do not need to ask for an override.
The second issue with the ICS department is the fact that many of the courses listed in the recommended plan template are general education courses. More courses within a certain semester should be available within the ICS department; there are almost two general education courses per semester in the program sheet. On the other hand, engineering has courses mostly pertinent to the major without room for many general education classes.
Finally, I wish that the ICS department would provide more resources, for example a computer lab. Even though engineers have a computer lab already, it is not geared towards software development. For example, it runs Windows and it does not have essential programs such as git, Python or gcc/g++.
I haven't been in the program for a long time since I transferred and also just switched over to CS last year, but I do see some things that could improve. I look at the classes on the STAR registration and some classes don't have any enrollment, which is unfortunate for others who had an interest in that class. Another way the ICS program could improve is the percentage of women that graduate with a CS degree because I know that it is fairly low compared to men. For the focus requirements, we have to complete 5 WI classes (writing intensive), and I only know of one or two classes that have this. I think it would be better to include for WI requirements in the classes so we don't have to take other electives and take up more time/credits.
1. Time of some of the courses. I know in previous years, ICS 211 and 311 were offered in the evening. Thankfully I function best at night so I didn't mind it, but I know for others it could be troublesome, especially if they commute or live far away.
2. I know in Engineering, they have sophomore, junior, and senior projects. I think incorporating it into ICS would be extremely helpful. It not only forces us to have good work ethics but also gives us something to showcase on our portfolio. I would love for the creation of a course that integrates multiple majors (Eg. Engineering, Math, ICS, etc...) and in that semester/year, you work together on a group project. I feel that it'll be an invaluable experience that mirrors real-life experiences that teach us how to work in groups and different minded individuals. Of course, an implementation of such a course would be challenging so even having just a commonplace (involving multiple majors) where people can look for team members would be great.
3. Internship course. In my other major, we had 3 courses (spanned over 3 semesters) dedicated to fieldwork. It would be great if ICS is able to reach out to other companies so we not only get real-life experience but also class credit for it!